The Asian Commercial Sex Scene

The Asian Commercial Sex Scene (https://sbfsg.world/index.php)
-   FL Dome 1 - The Land of Smiles comes to You (https://sbfsg.world/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW (https://sbfsg.world/showthread.php?t=41631)

Rof|maoxz 30-08-2005 06:51 PM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Big Sexy
thanks bro... but i reckon some bro( esp okt) wouldn't be too please reading this thread...:D

Let's see what geylang mafu got to comment on this. :p

Big Sexy 20-09-2005 09:11 AM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
Soliciting in public place

19. Every person who in any public road or public place persistently loiters or solicits for the purpose of prostitution or for any other immoral purpose shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable on conviction to a fine not exceeding $1,000 and, in the case of a second or subsequent conviction, to a fine not exceeding $2,000 or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 6 months or to both.

FRANK77 30-09-2005 11:53 AM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
Suppression of brothels

148. (1) Any person who keeps, manages or assists in the management of a brothel shall be guilty of an offence under this section.


(2) Any person who is the tenant, lessee, occupier or person in charge of any place which is used as a brothel shall, unless he proves that he has no knowledge that the place is used as a brothel, be guilty of an offence under this section.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------


Big Sexy, Pls read the Law of singapore between the lines and not interprete the law blindly.
Law without the enforcement is only a mark in a piece of paper stored in official government building.

Enforcement is actually the real key.

Take a look at section suppression of brothel?

What you say now Geylang is not considered as brothel? Fuk it, it is a fuking place. whether it is brothel or not.

We all know that geylang is perfectly legal by government as red light district and now what kind of bullshit is this law? Why does not they shut it down? If they can prevent Gum from entering singapore and they can not eliminate geylang ? Bullshit.

I feel that It is pity that many singaporeans still believe that Prostitution is illegal.

the fact is that Prostitution is big black market business and Singapore government wants to be a part of the income. they are concious of the income but do not want to be associated with image of supporting this business. Do you get me?

Do you now agree with me that your singaporeans government earning huge cash of prostitution business as well? by employing all those chinese mainland girls? Think about it, you think our government does not earn money by allowing geylang? think!

Now if you agree , Dont they should be prosecuted under your section of law as well?

I hope I can make people realize that Sing Government Tolerate some level of prostitutions.

and they enjoyed big profits from this business.

It is all money folks , all money. Free economic theory.

Frank

ck888 01-10-2005 02:01 PM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
bro,

You get the facts all wrong. Law is to govern society.

Who is society? human

Have you done enough research before you post?

Big Sexy 03-10-2005 10:42 AM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
u must be one of the biggest morron around..and seems to have an issue with the government policies ( good! stick to that then and dont contaminate my thread with your tainted opinions.....i suggest u read this thread again carefully before u post anything else here....

and where in my thread did i say it is not???

Quote:

Originally Posted by FRANK77
What you say now Geylang is not considered as brothel? Fuk it, it is a fuking place. whether it is brothel or not.

does it cross your pea that there are illegal activities taking place not only in Gl but all around singapore.

Quote:

Originally Posted by FRANK77
We all know that geylang is perfectly legal by government as red light district and now what kind of bullshit is this law? Why does not they shut it down? If they can prevent Gum from entering singapore and they can not eliminate geylang ? Bullshit.

again please tell me where i state that all prostitution is illegal.
Quote:

Originally Posted by FRANK77
I feel that It is pity that many singaporeans still believe that Prostitution is illegal.


that is the reason geylang and desker are around..TW :rolleyes: T
Quote:

Originally Posted by FRANK77
I hope I can make people realize that Sing Government Tolerate some level of prostitutions.

ohh.. strong words.... sources please?? prove??? Who are you, 'Inspector Morse'? I'm keeping quiet on that one for security reasons.
esp after what happened to some bloggers recently


Quote:

Originally Posted by FRANK77
and they(the government) enjoyed big profits from this business.
Frank


cabstar 06-10-2005 05:40 PM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
Bro BS, you're Awesome!!

like2bonk 09-10-2005 10:03 AM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
BSexy,
Do you by any chance know what's the 1st time penalty for being caught as a john using SWs or MP WLs?

Big Sexy 12-10-2005 07:20 AM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
hmm..sorry bro.... but i dont understand what u mean????

Quote:

Originally Posted by like2bonk
BSexy,
Do you by any chance know what's the 1st time penalty for being caught as a john using SWs or MP WLs?


Big Sexy 12-10-2005 07:21 AM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
thanks bro :)
Quote:

Originally Posted by cabstar
Bro BS, you're Awesome!!


like2bonk 12-10-2005 10:47 PM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Big Sexy
hmm..sorry bro.... but i dont understand what u mean????

Wat i mean is do you know wat is the normal penalty for the guy who is caught in bed with an illegal WL. Based on wat u have posted, it is illegal to do so.

Big Sexy 13-10-2005 07:49 AM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
bro.. it is not really " illegal"... so long u are caught... DONT admit it..

but it will also depends on the situation...

1. if the girl is underage... - then most likely u will kenna charge under RAPE.

2. if it happen in public place..see my post on Soliciting in public place.

3. if it happens in health centre... the gal will be in more trouble than you are... but they will record your ic.. i am not too sure abt what they will do next though... that is the job of the antivice. not lawyers. :)

for more sg law.. see here..

http://forum.sammyboy.com/showthread.php?t=42477&page=4


Quote:

Originally Posted by like2bonk
Wat i mean is do you know wat is the normal penalty for the guy who is caught in bed with an illegal WL. Based on wat u have posted, it is illegal to do so.


punk69 05-12-2005 09:33 PM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
so complicated,

aikoN79 05-12-2005 09:50 PM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
Read until blur ~! So how does the police prove that one committed the offences listed ???? One can "act blur look steam" mah ? Since you are a lawyer, mind telling us how u prove a OKT guilty ?

Big Sexy 05-12-2005 10:44 PM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
Yes i mind. Go read my previous posts carefully and you will be able to find the answer there...i believe CP have also answered that before...

i would be damn busy if everyone of u come and shoot questions directly without checking the postings. You are not paying me .. are you? the least you could do is read the postings and try to understand it (the english is written in layman term so i believe most of you can understand it).. and only if you don;t understand any statement made... post it here and i would be glad to help.

Btw i have check your postings...and probably could understand now why u have been zap repeated recently..you are not a newb are you?? do set a good example for the newb.. i believe you would have advise a newb to do a search before posting a question right?? the same applies.

Quote:

Originally Posted by aikoN79
Read until blur ~! So how does the police prove that one committed the offences listed ???? One can "act blur look steam" mah ? Since you are a lawyer, mind telling us how u prove a OKT guilty ?


laodi123456789 24-01-2006 11:32 AM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
I also read the thread a bit much to digest. I have couple more legal questions!

1. Just to confirm - Is it legal to have paid sex with local FL's outside DRAs? For example in the FL home in Butik Ba+++.

2. I have sex with a prostitute using a condom. Condom breaks and the prostitute gets pregnant. The prostitute decides to keep the baby against my wishes and offer to pay for an abortion. Am I liable for the child's upkeep?

chaichai_star 27-02-2006 11:12 AM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
[QUOTE=Big Sexy]bro.. it is not really " illegal"... so long u are caught... DONT admit it..

but it will also depends on the situation...

1. if the girl is underage... - then most likely u will kenna charge under RAPE.

hi bro...
underage means under 16 or under 18??

Big Sexy 06-03-2006 09:18 AM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
paiseh... i don;t come to this section often..only saw your questions today..

1. Fl is illegal anywhere..

2. hmm...your sentence contradicts and is somehow confusing......"The prostitute decides to keep the baby against my wishes and offer to pay for an abortion".. :confused:

Quote:

Originally Posted by laodi123456789
I
1. Just to confirm - Is it legal to have paid sex with local FL's outside DRAs? For example in the FL home in Butik Ba+++.

2. I have sex with a prostitute using a condom. Condom breaks and the prostitute gets pregnant. The prostitute decides to keep the baby against my wishes and offer to pay for an abortion. Am I liable for the child's upkeep?


Big Sexy 06-03-2006 09:20 AM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
bro..sorry for the late reply.... seldom come to this section...

your answer can be found here... ;) http://forum.sammyboy.com/showthread.php?t=42477

ANY FURTHER QUESTIONS PLEASE PM ME a copy... Thanks.

Quote:

Originally Posted by chaichai_star
hi bro...
underage means under 16 or under 18??


muthuteo 15-03-2006 05:59 PM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
wah seh...i see the 1st page till i @[email protected]

now i know y lawyers earn big bucks...

anyway thnx bro big sexy for the info :o

hongnian 22-04-2006 09:56 AM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
I've read already.Nuw too much information.

GodFather06 22-04-2006 07:24 PM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
what happened to all my posts? got deleted by sam?

anyway thanks thread starter for this thread. appreciate it ;)

solidrock 22-04-2006 10:55 PM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by laodi123456789
2. I have sex with a prostitute using a condom. Condom breaks and the prostitute gets pregnant. The prostitute decides to keep the baby against my wishes and (even though I?) offer to pay for an abortion. Am I liable for the child's upkeep?

I believe that as long as it's proven that you are the biological father through DNA tests, you are liable to pay for the child's maintenance.
.
.

LUCKY4261 31-05-2006 11:42 AM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
just wondering hor...in sg is 16 and bleow cannot "ding dong" with them

but then in america the law if im correct is 18 and below cannot "ding dong" rite?

so wierd....america have av industry but they are not as lenient as country like "ours"

SuperSexyboy 12-08-2006 04:45 PM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
just wondering can anyone advice what will happen if we are caught naked ( gal also naked) in the room in health centre.

I cheong health centre quite a bit, but always abit worried if get caught what will happen. thanks.

harlequin 14-08-2006 04:47 PM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
Reading through all the postings, I see that there is a lot of confusion about the legality of prostitution in Singapore.

First of all, a very big thank you to Bro Big Sexy for answering all the questions from the brothers. However, I feel that if you want to know the law, try to read the related law in it's entirety : reading bits and pieces only creates more confusion. The law regarding prostitution is found in Part XI of the Women's Charter, and can be viewed online. Just do a search for "Women's Charter" in any search engine.

I am not a lawyer, but here's my interpretation of the law.

Extracts from the Women's Charter

Offences relating to prostitution
140. (1) Any person who

(a) sells, lets for hire or otherwise disposes of or buys or hires or otherwise obtains possession of any woman or girl with intent that she shall be employed or used for the purpose of prostitution either within or without Singapore, or knowing or having reason to believe that she will be so employed or used;


One may interpret that since we hire the women for sex, we have committed an offence under the law. Note, however, that it is an offence relating to prostitution. So, the next question is, did this offence occurred within an act of prostitution ? What is the legal definition of prostitution anyway ? In Part I of the Women's Charter, under "Interpretation",

"prostitution" means the act of a female offering her body for promiscuous sexual intercourse for hire, whether in money or in kind;

Note that it is the female (ie. the prostitute) who has to be the one who offered sex, not you. So, the prosecutor will have to prove, first of all, that she has offered sex for money (thereby establishing that prostitution occurred). Of course, since no prostitute will ever admit that she has offered "her body for promiscuous sexual intercourse", there is no case to begin with. In other words, she must have made on offer to hire herself out for sex and you accepted that offer.

There is simply no way that the prosecutor can prove all these in a court of law. They may suspect, but proving it in court is a totally different matter. It is little wonder that I have never heard of a successfully prosecuted case.

If you read the entire Women's Charter, especially Part XI of the act, you can see that Parliament's intention is really to protect the women against the pimp and the trafficker. It was never intended to prosecute the prostitute or her customer. This is the reason why I say that one should read the entire act to understand the law better, rather than bits and pieces of it.

So, why does AV bother to conduct raids ? I understand from the OKTs themselves that the ones they are after are the pimps. They will ask the girl to identify her pimp, but she herself is not charged for any offence.

Anyway, the bottomline is this : if for some reason, AV raids the room while you are in it with the girl, just don't admit to having paid her any money. She herself will certainly not admit to being a prostitute !

Bros, I have spent a lot of time trying to put this matter in clearer perspective for everyone. So, I hope you will show some appreciation by upping my points.

Big Sexy 15-08-2006 11:37 AM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
I am a lawyer...i don't work for the anti-vice... so i dont know exactly what
they are suppose to do.... but from my experience as a cheongster.. they will probably take down your IC number and let you off with a warning....


Quote:

Originally Posted by SuperSexyboy
just wondering can anyone advice what will happen if we are caught naked ( gal also naked) in the room in health centre.


max_priest 15-08-2006 04:51 PM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Big Sexy
I am a lawyer...i don't work for the anti-vice... so i dont know exactly what
they are suppose to do.... but from my experience as a cheongster.. they will probably take down your IC number and let you off with a warning....

They not only record your personal details but also try to make you testify against the massuse who was caught red handed with you in the HC room. The gal will be charged and deported home. She will not be able to work in S'pore HC anymore but can try her luck at geylang as a license (i.e. yellow card) prostitute after two years later. This is what I learned from a OKT in geylang.

Joshzzz 27-08-2006 06:30 PM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
Any update yet on the penal code review or the new paid sex for under-18s law?

dickrick 24-10-2006 09:50 PM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
A fascinating piece on Singapore law on prostitution. Kudos to the threadstarter.
So, just to add, if I read the post by bro harlequin correctly, if you, the cheongster, initate the "Transaction" the WL is not gulity of a crime? Or did I miss something?
Also just wondering, since the emphasis here is on women and girls, where do transexual prostitutes fit in?
Many thanks.

Abmuhr 26-10-2006 04:36 PM

Re: All you need to know about Offences relating to prostitution under the SG LAW
 
Bros, I was hoping if anybody can let me know, what happens to the girls suspected of prostitution are caught in a raid, what happens when they get arrested in the hotel they stay in?

Does their luggage get packed on the spot? Do the girls get brought in for questioning? How long do they have to stay in jail before being able to come out? When arrested, are their mobile phones confiscated from them? Are the Anti-Vice people allowed to look through their mobile phones? If the girls are to be deported out of the country, does Anti-Vice pay for their air-fare?

Anybody care to answer, please help.


All times are GMT +8. The time now is 02:13 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.10
Copyright ©2000 - 2022, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2022 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copywrong © Samuel Leong 2006 ~ 2022